When competitors collaborate: the role of joint industry projects in advancing industry standards
Article

When competitors collaborate: the role of joint industry projects in advancing industry standards

  • Home
  • Insights
  • When competitors collaborate: the role of joint industry projects in advancing industry standards
  • linkedin icon
  • twitter icon
  • facebook icon
  • youtube icon
  • instagram icon

Organisations may compete for contracts, market share and investment, but many of the technical challenges they face are remarkably similar.

That is one reason joint industry projects (JIPs) continue to play an important role across the energy, materials and infrastructure sectors. By bringing together operators, manufacturers, engineering specialists, researchers and regulators, JIPs create an environment where organisations can tackle shared challenges collectively while protecting commercially sensitive information.

The benefits are often more practical than many people realise.  During a JIP workshop, someone may receive an update from colleagues dealing with an unexpected reliability issue, emerging failure mechanism or operational challenge. As conversations develop around the table, another participant may recognise the problem immediately.

"We've seen that before."

Those four words can save months, and sometimes years, of investigation.

In one industry discussion, an operator described its experience managing a subsea pipeline failure mechanism that had required several years of investigation and remediation. Another operator, working on assets thousands of miles away, recognised the same early warning signs beginning to appear within its own operation. Access to lessons already learned allowed the second organisation to focus on proven mitigation measures rather than repeating the same investigations from the beginning.

Experiences like this explain why JIPs continue to attract participation from organisations that would otherwise be competitors. The opportunity to share knowledge, understand emerging risks and learn from real-world operational experience often delivers benefits that extend well beyond the formal objectives of a project.

Why some challenges are too big for one organisation to solve

Many engineering challenges are too expensive, too complex or too uncommon for a single organisation to investigate alone.

Subsea equipment reliability, flexible pipe degradation, marine fouling, hydrogen transportation, carbon dioxide transportation and integrity management are all examples where the industry benefits from combining operational experience from multiple asset owners, vendors and technical specialists.

When organisations pool data, compare performance trends and share lessons learned, patterns often become visible much earlier than they would within an individual company. This can accelerate investigations, improve decision-making and support the development of more effective engineering practices.

Over time, the outcomes often find their way into engineering guidance, recommended practices and industry standards, helping the wider sector benefit from collective experience.

From subsea reliability to energy transition infrastructure

Wood has participated in and led a range of collaborative initiatives covering subsea systems, asset integrity and emerging energy infrastructure.

These include long-running programmes such as the SURF IM Network, which brings operators together to share experience relating to subsea umbilicals, risers and flexibles integrity management.  The Sureflex programme is another, drawing on more than two decades of industry data to support the safe operation and integrity management of flexible pipe systems.

The value of these initiatives comes from their ability to identify degradation trends, understand emerging failure mechanisms and evaluate inspection and monitoring technologies using a much broader evidence base than any single operator could assemble alone.

Collaboration has also helped address subsea equipment reliability challenges. The SEAR (Subsea Equipment Australia Reliability) JIP was established to improve understanding of subsea equipment performance in Australia's offshore environment, bringing together operators, vendors and technical specialists to investigate reliability issues, marine fouling and equipment design improvements.

The project focused on identifying root causes, improving equipment design, evaluating remediation strategies and sharing lessons that could improve reliability across the industry.

Beyond reliability and integrity management, JIPs increasingly play a role in supporting the energy transition.

Industry initiatives such as H₂Pipe and CO₂PipeSafe have helped close knowledge gaps and establish best practices for the design and operation of hydrogen and carbon dioxide transportation systems. At the same time, participation in committees and standards bodies including API SC17, DNV and ASME helps ensure that operational experience and research findings contribute to the evolution of industry guidance.

One of the most significant recent examples is the development of industry guidelines for setting CO₂ specifications across carbon capture, utilisation and storage (CCUS) value chains. Developed through collaboration between operators, researchers and technical specialists, the guidance brings together knowledge covering CO₂ capture, transport, materials selection, corrosion, safety and geological storage.

By creating a shared understanding of how impurities affect the entire CCUS chain, the project has provided practical guidance for an industry that is growing rapidly and still developing its operational experience. It also demonstrates how collaboration can accelerate the development of new sectors by helping organisations solve common challenges collectively.

Engineering professionals sharing knowledge

How collaboration helped improve subsea cable design guidance

The benefits of JIPs can be seen clearly in the CABILITY (Cable On-Bottom Stability) Joint Industry Project.

As offshore wind, tidal and other marine energy projects expanded, industry participants recognised that existing approaches for assessing cable stability had largely been adapted from methodologies originally developed for oil and gas pipelines.

This often resulted in conservative recommendations that could increase project costs and require unnecessary stabilisation measures.

Bringing together developers, contractors, manufacturers and technical specialists allowed the industry to investigate the problem collectively. The project combined numerical modelling, laboratory testing and operational experience to develop guidance specifically tailored to subsea power cables.

The resulting methodology improved understanding of cable behaviour on rocky and non-smooth seabeds, helping developers make more informed design decisions while maintaining technical robustness.

The project highlights an important feature of many JIPs. Success is not always measured by the invention of a new technology. In many cases, the greatest value comes from improving understanding, reducing uncertainty and creating better guidance for future projects.

The value of shared operational experience

The outputs of a JIP are usually tangible. New guidelines, shared datasets, recommended practices, technology assessments and research findings all provide measurable value.

The conversations that take place throughout the process can be equally important.

Participants gain exposure to different operating environments, alternative approaches and lessons learned from projects around the world. They hear about challenges that may not yet have emerged within their own organisations. They learn what worked, what failed and what others would do differently next time.

Many of the most valuable lessons shared within JIPs never appear in a published report. They emerge through discussion, challenge and the exchange of practical experience between people facing similar issues in different parts of the world.

As industries navigate increasingly complex technical, environmental and operational challenges, the ability to learn from one another remains a significant advantage.

Joint industry projects provide a structured way to do exactly that, helping organisations accelerate learning, reduce uncertainty and contribute to safer, more reliable and more effective industry practices. Whether the focus is subsea integrity, infrastructure reliability, hydrogen transportation, carbon capture or future energy systems, the principle remains the same: some challenges are solved faster when expertise is shared.

Related content